The fashionable ideas these days: to
follow your own heart, do what you like, find your passion and the iconic Stay Hungry
Stay Foolish have one thing in common. All of them collectively owe some part
of their origin to one book: Fountainhead. It is one of those books which have had
influence across generations. One of the most influential books of 20th century,
Fountainhead talks primarily about the triumph of the individual over society. The
book splits the world into two kinds:
the first hander who relies on his own thinking and the second hander who
borrows from ideas and values from the independent thinkers
Howard Roark is the epitome of the first hander man. He
stands up for himself and his ideas. He does not follow the laid down
norms of society. For Roark, his individualism is the way he contributes to the advancement
of society. He truly believes in his values and more importantly, he is willing to
stand for them against the society. He considers originality as the
highest ideal for humans to achieve.He is a man who has the potential of greatness and is willing to
risk everything to achieve it. Roark considers the individual contributions of
the people as the reason that humanity has been able to make any advancement.
He fiercely guards his own values and judgments. The trouble with Howard Roark is that he does
not give society what it wants. The society expects submission to its rules and
norms and he does not give in to the compulsion.
Peter Keating on the other hand is
painted as the unoriginal man who gets success merely because he knows his way
around the world. His focus is on giving the society what it wants to get the fame and
success in return. He wants to win the admiration of people
even if it is not his own work that is giving the success. To put it
dramatically, he wants Keating wants the admiration of men, while Roark wants the admiration
of Gods. Peter does not have the strength to stand for his ideas. He seeks
validation so desperately that he is willing to trade anything for it, his
friends, his wife even his own self. Ayn Rand terms him as the self 'less' man in a very literal sense that he
has given up on his own self. The only thing he wants is the prestige and admiration
in the eyes of others even if it comes at
the cost of his own ideas.
It is pretty evident that Ayn Rand
wants people to be a first hander and to go with their individual thought. According
to her, collectivism is the root of all the evils in society from Fascism to
Communism to World War.
But being a first hander also
comes with its own set of challenges. A glaring example would be the duo of Tesla-Edison.
Nobody could be more original than Tesla but in his final days he died alone in
a hotel room. Nobody could be more derivative than Edison and he is celebrated
like anything in this world to the extent that all of us have read about his 1000
failed attempts to invent a bulb which apparently taught him 1000 ways to not
make a bulb instead of de-motivating him.
We really cannot say what is right
or wrong and like everything else in life it is really difficult to paint the
picture black and white.The world cannot be so easily divided into binaries. But yes, this is a line of thought that is worth pondering over. Ultimately, it is you who makes the decision about what you want .The two characters of Howard Roark and Peter Keating portray the extreme ends of the spectrum and I
feel most of us are in the middle. The key here is not to find the perfect point
on the spectrum but to find your own
self on the spectrum and be true to it.